• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Trending:
  • Kashmir
  • Elections
Sunday, June 22, 2025

Daily Times

Your right to know

  • HOME
  • Latest
  • Iran-Israel Tensions
  • Pakistan
    • Balochistan
    • Gilgit Baltistan
    • Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    • Punjab
    • Sindh
  • World
  • Editorials & Opinions
    • Editorials
    • Op-Eds
    • Commentary / Insight
    • Perspectives
    • Cartoons
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Featured
    • Blogs
      • Pakistan
      • World
      • Ramblings
      • Lifestyle
      • Culture
      • Sports
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • E-PAPER
    • Lahore
    • Islamabad
    • Karachi

Indian army can’t get away with extrajudicial killings

The recent judgment of the Indian Supreme Court rejecting petitions filed by 350 army men praying for quashing the first information reports, which had been been filed against them for extrajudicial killings in “encounters” in Manipur, Kashmir, and some other states, must be welcomed by all supporters of the rule of law, civil liberties and human rights.

The states in which these alleged extrajudicial killings occurred were declared to be “disturbed areas” under the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act, 1958. That Act was enacted as a temporary measure, but as someone remarked, if after 60 years a “temporary” act continues to operate, one wonders what would be a permanent act ? In fact the Justice B.P. Jeevan Reddy Committee appointed by government of India recommended its repeal.

The AFSPA grants immunity to army personnel for shooting at people who they think are likely to create disorder. But it certainly does not authorise fake encounters or other kinds of atrocities.

A petition was filed in the Supreme Court, Extra Judicial Execution Victims Family Association and Human Rights Alert versus Union of India mentioning 1528 cases of extrajudicial executions by army and police personnel between 1979 and 2012 in the state of Manipur. The prayer was that these be investigated by the Central Bureau of Investigations. The Court appointed a committee consisting of retired Supreme Court Justice Santosh Hegde as its chairman, and including Mr. Lyndoh, former Chief Election Commissioner as a member, to enquire into some of the complaints, and the committee found many of them prima facie correct. Consequently, the Court ordered registration of FIRs against the alleged army and police personnel and an investigation by the CBI, prompted the army, para military and police personnel implicated in fake encounters to approach the Supreme Court.

The court acted correctly in rejecting the petition. Army personnel must know they are not above the law and cannot get away with anything as long as there is a constitution guaranteeing fundamental rights, including the right to life and liberty under Article 21. If it is the army of the Indian people, it cannot commit atrocities on the Indian people.

In the Nuremburg Trials held after the Second World War in 1945, the Nazi war criminals, including Field Marshal Keitel and General Jodl, took the plea of  “orders are orders,” but their plea was rejected and several accused were hanged. It was found that Keitel and Jodl had signed several orders for committing atrocities during the war, which were against the Geneva Conventions and other laws of war. They took the plea that they did so only under instructions from Hitler, their superior, but The International Tribunal held that carrying out illegal orders cannot absolve anyone.

Justice Lokur, who presided over the bench which decided the case is retiring next month. He will go down as one in judicial history who always upheld liberty, as in his decision in Dataram Singh versus State of Uttar Pradesh in which he reiterated the principle laid down by the celebrated Justice Krishna Iyer in State of Rajasthan versus Balchand, that bail not jail is the normal rule, a stark contrast to the judges who rejected the bail plea of the journalist Abhijit Iyer Mitra, whose only “crime” was that he posted a satirical tweet about the Kobark temple (for which he immediately apologised), and is still rotting in jail.

Filed Under: Blogs, World Tagged With: extrajudicial killings, Indian Supreme Court

Submit a Comment




Primary Sidebar




Latest News

Justice Mansoor Ali Shah opposes bench extension without 26th amendment verdict

FM Dar, COAS Asim Munir meet president Erdogan, discuss regional peace

Lahore welcomes rain as weather turns pleasant after days of humidity

Dar tells OIC: Iran has full right to defend itself against Israeli aggression

Only state can declare jihad, says ISPR DG in call for national unity

Pakistan

Justice Mansoor Ali Shah opposes bench extension without 26th amendment verdict

FM Dar, COAS Asim Munir meet president Erdogan, discuss regional peace

Lahore welcomes rain as weather turns pleasant after days of humidity

Dar tells OIC: Iran has full right to defend itself against Israeli aggression

Only state can declare jihad, says ISPR DG in call for national unity

More Posts from this Category

Business

Israel-Tehran conflict cripples border trade between Pakistan and Iran

Europeans seek ‘digital sovereignty’ as US tech firms embrace Trump

Pakistan, Russia reaffirm to deepen energy cooperation

Gold price per tola gains Rs1,465

Technical session on budget 2025–26 and economic policy held at Punjab Assembly

More Posts from this Category

World

Global reactions pour in after U.S. strikes Iran: condemnations and pleas for peace

Iran vows to defend itself after ‘outrageous’ U.S. strikes on nuclear sites

Israel pushes for swift strike on Iran as U.S. leadership remains divided

More Posts from this Category




punjab

Footer

Home
Lead Stories
Latest News
Editor’s Picks

Culture
Life & Style
Featured
Videos

Editorials
OP-EDS
Commentary
Advertise

Cartoons
Letters
Blogs
Privacy Policy

Contact
Company’s Financials
Investor Information
Terms & Conditions

Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
Youtube

© 2025 Daily Times. All rights reserved.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkPrivacy policy