US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner faced a packed diplomatic schedule on Tuesday in Geneva, juggling talks on Iran’s nuclear program and Russia’s war in Ukraine. The dual negotiations, arranged by US President Donald Trump, raised concerns over whether the envoys were overstretched and if either crisis could be resolved effectively. Experts questioned the strategy, highlighting the high stakes and complexity of both conflicts.
The Iran talks, mediated by Oman, lasted three-and-a-half hours and involved indirect discussions between the US team and Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araqchi. Both sides reported some progress, but no immediate agreement emerged on the long-standing nuclear dispute. Meanwhile, US military presence near Iran underscores that the use of force remains a strategic option, keeping regional tensions high.
Read more: China, Russia, Iran forge strategic alliance
Immediately after the Iran discussions, Witkoff and Kushner moved to the InterContinental hotel in Geneva for the first round of Russia-Ukraine talks. Expectations for a breakthrough were low, given the ongoing conflict and Trump’s previous campaign promises to end the war quickly. Observers said handling both crises simultaneously risked overstretch and reduced the likelihood of success.
Critics highlighted that both envoys, drawn from Trump’s New York business circle, may lack the experience to negotiate effectively with seasoned officials like Araqchi or Russian representatives. Absence of Secretary of State Marco Rubio raised further concerns about the administration’s diplomatic capacity. Former officials described a hollowed-out foreign policy apparatus as undermining US negotiating strength.
Read more: Aleem Khan meets Russian, Iranian ministers to boost connectivity
Supporters defended Witkoff and Kushner as trusted dealmakers, citing their roles in the Abraham Accords and Gaza ceasefire, but progress on both fronts has stalled. Analysts warn that without deeper expertise and support from experienced diplomats, the US risks failure in handling two of the world’s most complex crises at once.