In a heartbreaking twist that defies the growing expectations of a return to normalcy, a tragic attack on an aid convoy in Kurram claimed the lives of ten innocent individuals. Making one wonder about how long the region will remain ensnared in a cycle of violence, this incident starkly reflects the challenges surrounding security in the picturesque valley, where a November 21 ambush on civilian passenger convoys was enough to plunge tens of thousands of residents into a nightmarish ordeal. The past few weeks have laid bare the fragile peace that once seemed achievable, exposing deep-rooted systemic issues that the provincial government has consistently disregarded. For years, the people of Kurram have tiptoed a landscape fraught with sectarian tensions, living in a state of precariousness as they yearn for a semblance of routine life. After what appeared to be an exclusive interest in blame-tossing, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s efforts to secure a peace deal sparked cautious optimism, leading to the dismantling of bunkers that symbolized a tumultuous past. However, the harsh reality raises doubts about whether this optimistic narrative is merely a façade that obscures the region’s true needs. Ergo, all claims of progress achieved, especially in a recent statement by Chief Minister’s Advisor on Information Barrister Saif ring hollow against the backdrop of ongoing violence. As fear permeates the communities that authorities claim to protect, we must confront the discomforting question: can we continue to accept such complacency from those entrusted with governance when ensuring public safety should be their foremost priority? Their lack of engagement with local voices and neglect of community-led reconciliation efforts contribute to an atmosphere that is ripe for extremism. Where was the said interest when humanitarian voices were urgently highlighting malnutrition taking hold? In a misguided response, the decision to seal roads forced locals to grapple with severe shortages of food and medical supplies. No qualms about that. Each loss – whether from preventable diseases like pneumonia, confrontations with the state, or longstanding land disputes – represents a missed opportunity for healing. While the government may pay lip service to prioritizing the safety of humanitarian workers, rebuilding trust among the masses will take time. The scars run deep, and mere promises will not suffice in this environment of fear and instability. *