The New York jurors ruled in the newspaper’s favor a day after the judge presiding over the case said he would dismiss the libel lawsuit irrespective of their verdict. The civil trial was viewed by legal experts as a test case for the US Constitution’s First Amendment that protects free speech and journalistic freedom of expression.
The bar to prove defamation in the United States is high, due to a famous 1964 Supreme Court ruling known as the New York Times v. Sullivan. A plaintiff needs to show that the defendant intended to cause harm. It is not sufficient to demonstrate that an error was made.
The ruling shields journalists from liability if they make unintentional errors. District Judge Jed Rakoff said Monday he would toss out the case because Palin’s lawyers had failed to prove that the Times had acted with actual malice.
He added that he would allow the jury to reach a verdict anyway because it would “greatly benefit” a court when it hears Palin’s likely appeal. The editorial linked a 2011 shooting in Arizona that wounded lawmaker Gabrielle Giffords and killed six others with an ad run by Palin’s political action committee.
The ad, which ran shortly before the attack, showed Gifford’s congressional district in the crosshairs of a firearm. The Times corrected the editorial the next day, saying there was nothing that could demonstrate that the perpetrator had been driven to act by that controversial ad.
Palin, a former governor of Alaska, was Republican candidate John McCain’s running mate during his 2008 election defeat to Barack Obama.
The 100-Index of the Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX) witnessed bullish trend on Monday, gaining 158.08…
The President, Asian Development Bank (ADB), Masatsugu Asakawa here on Monday lauded the government for…
The Board of Directors (BoD) of Sui Southern Gas Company Limited (SSGCL), Pakistan’s premier natural…
Gunvor Group Torbjorn Tornqvist Chairman and Vice Oceania & Southeast Asia Total Energies President Mehmet…
Pakistani rupee on Monday appreciated by 04 paisa against the US dollar in the interbank…
The per tola price of 24 karat gold increased by Rs.1,700 and was sold at…
Leave a Comment