The Debate behind Jury Trials

Author: Ziyad Broker

Modern American legal dramas often showcase the importance of a jury — the representation of an everyday individual; normal citizens across many different demographics helping to run an exclusive branch of government. In doing so, they are often celebrated for helping bring about justice.

Yet, many countries including Pakistan have made jury trials rare — causing a lengthy and ongoing debate in the legal sphere.

On the one hand, jury trials allow for a slew of perspectives and opinions from a diverse set of people to be considered when making a legal decision. But, others argue that a judicial system reliant on jury trials is not only hard to manage logistically — but it can also lead to incorrect decisions based on hunches, biases, or a plain lack of legal understanding.

And this is the primary dilemma that every nation’s judiciary system faces: Should the opinion of the public be considered with a larger risk, or should the margin of error be reduced, and the general population ignored?

However, a component of Jury trials in developing countries still yet to be explored is the impact of corruption in both circumstances.

It is a common fact that, in the past, judges have indeed been bribed to make a certain decision. But, what is not as known, is the corruption that can occur with regards to juries — and in a multitude of ways. Aside from the traditional bribe, other methods juries have used to affect the outcome of a trial include breaking rules with regards to information available on the internet. This often goes unnoticed on the surface — but any influence from the media can skew somebody’s opinion of a case; thereby possessing the potential to affect the outcome of the trial.

It is mainly for this reason, that in developing countries, juries aren’t common, and will continue not to be. Coupled with low education rates, which is another factor that could affect the outcome of trials — it seems logical that only countries with a specified literacy rate should be allowed to have jury trials — for the sake of justice.

Share
Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

  • Pakistan

NADRA denies policy change on AJK residency status for CNICs

The National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) has clarified the procedure for including the designation…

6 seconds ago
  • Pakistan

Need stressed for robust efforts to save youth from tobacco hazards

In a significant step towards combating the growing tobacco epidemic among Pakistan’s youth, the Society…

11 seconds ago
  • Pakistan

Exports to Europe rise to $3.8bn in first 5 months of FY

Pakistan’s exports to Europe surged to 3.8 billion dollars, reflecting an 8.62 per cent increase…

37 seconds ago
  • Pakistan

Pakistan, Turkish navies hold bilateral exercise in Mediterranean Sea

The Pakistan Navy and Turkish Navy successfully conducted bilateral exercise TURGUTREIS-XI in the Eastern Mediterranean…

42 seconds ago
  • Pakistan

EPA decides crackdown on smoky government vehicles

The Punjab government has decided to enforce a strict crackdown on government vehicles that contribute…

2 mins ago
  • Pakistan

Heavy snowfall blankets Kaghan Valley, Galyat

Much awaited rain in the plains and snowfall in the upper regions of Hazara division…

4 mins ago