NAB’s report to SC uncovers biggest fraud in hospital waste case

Author: Samiullah Randhawa

The famous company for incinerating the hospital waste in Punjab has been found guilty over the allegations of not disposing the hospital waste scientifically while minting the money fraudulently.

This has been revealed in a report of National Accountability Bureau (NAB) presented in Supreme Court of Pakistan while report also held responsible three officials of Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in link to Ali Traders Waste Management Company (AT Waste), the infamous company which has been providing services to the hospitals and industries to incinerate their infectious waste since 2012.

Experts have been warned over the issue of misuse of hospital waste in country, particularly in Punjab while the issue has been highlighted in media times and again. Despite all concerns, authorities remained reluctant to control the menace which helped the violators to play with the lives of citizens. However, the SC in a matter regarding the Disposal of Hospital and Sewerage Waste had directed NAB to conduct an inquiry into the contracts of the M/S A.T Waste Management Company, Kasur. During the probe the committee of experts, there found a score of embezzlements and misappropriations since the company started its operation.

This has been revealed that the said company got Environmental Approval from EPA for incinerating 100-150 Kg/hour on August 30, 2011. During its operation, the owner of the company requested EPA officials to increase the capacity of incineration up to 400kg/hour.

NAB officials found that the EPA officials malafidely increased the capacity of incineration in the substituted Environmental Approval. In report this was alleged that Deputy Director EIA Naseem-ur-Rehman, the then Assistant Director EIA Riaz Ahmad and the then Inspector Muffakir Ahsan prima facie involved in the said illegal act of misusing authority.

EPA officials malafidely increased the capacity of incineration of company in the substituted Environmental Approval

It is pertinent to mention here that prior to allowing such amendment in the operation capacity, no physical inspection/ verification of the operation site of the incinerator was conducted by EPA officials to ascertain whether the capacity of the plant was enhanced by the owner or not. NAB report further states, “No approval was sought from the competent authority for issuance of Environmental Approval, which clearly reveal that the EPA officials were hand in glove with the owner of the firm.”

During the visit of team of NAB and experts, this was found that the plant/incinerator was operational at full load i.e 450kg/hour while the combustion efficiency of the plant was found beyond the Punjab Environmental Quality Standards (PEQS) limits. “An excessive pressure resulting in the leakage of emissions at height of 12-15 feet was observed which cleared that plant’s capacity was not 450kg/hour as contended by the owner of the company,” report revealed.

The prime responsibility of the firm was to incinerate the hazardous hospital/ industrial waste in a scientific way but firm found not incinerating such hazardous material rather kept on defrauding its clients on account of its so-called incineration services. “It was discovered that the firm merely kept on burying/ dumping incinerated/ unburnt hospital/ industrial waste rather to incinerate the same as was required under the terms and conditions of the contracts(s),” report revealed.

Report concluded that the owners of the firm were found involved in corruption and corrupt practices by gaining illegal pecuniary advantages to the tune of Rs524.10 million on the pretext of their so-called incineration services . “From the past record of the waste collection, capacity of the plant and data of electricity consumption of the firm, it is established that the firm fraudulently collected the said amount from its clients without providing them the services of incineration,” report contended.

While highlighting the negligence on part of EPA, report states that the poor monitoring of EPA officials provided opportunity to the owner of the firm to enter into large number of contracts, for which the firm did not possess requisite capacity, equipment and manpower.

Published in Daily Times, February 13th 2019.

Share
Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

  • Technology

Digital Innovation: Transforming Pakistan’s Trade Infrastructure

  Pakistan's logistics industry stands at a critical crossroads, grappling with significant challenges that impede…

10 hours ago
  • Top Stories

EU expresses concern over military court sentences against May 9 rioters

The European Union (EU) has expressed concern over the sentencing of 25 individuals involved in…

10 hours ago
  • Pakistan

Ahsan Kamray Elected President of Lahore Garrison University Alumni Association

Lahore Garrison University (LGU) celebrated a milestone event as its Department of Mass Communication organized…

10 hours ago
  • Fashion

Neo Hum Bridal Couture Week 2024: Grand Finale Celebrates Fashion and Social Change

Lahore, Pakistan – December 22, 2024 – The highly anticipated finale of Neo Hum Bridal…

10 hours ago
  • Top Stories

US lifts $10 million bounty on new Syrian leader after talks in Damascus

The United States has removed a $10 million bounty on Ahmed al-Sharaa, the leader of…

11 hours ago
  • Pakistan

Accountability Court postpones verdict in £190 million case

An accountability court hearing the £190 million case involving Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) founder Imran Khan…

11 hours ago