Daily Times

GENEVA: The US claimed its seat Monday on the Human Rights Council under the new presidency of Donald Trump, whose election has provoked deep concern over the body’s future.

Over its 11-year history, the council has come in for criticism, including allegations that it has, at times, been co-opted by rights abusers who push resolutions attacking their geopolitical rivals, with genuine rights issues marginalised. But the 47-member panel has had successes — thanks to support from Barack Obama’s administration which held a seat on the council for most of his eight-year term, civil society groups say. Many of the issues prioritised by Obama’s UN envoys — including violations in North Korea, Myanmar, Sri Lanka and South Sudan — remain on the agenda.

In a keynote address, United Nations Secretary General Antonio Guterres warned that the world was facing “a time of urgency” and that the council was needed more than ever. “Disregard for human rights is a disease, and it is a disease that is spreading,” he said. “The Human Rights Council must be part of the cure.” Trump’s State Department has not yet named an envoy to the body and was represented at Monday’s session by veteran foreign service officer Erin Barclay.

Trump’s international agenda remains murky but rights advocates have warned that the early signs do not bode well for either the council or the broader human rights agenda. “Clearly ‘America First’ does not suggest an approach that (prioritises) multilateral engagement,” said John Fisher of Human Rights Watch (HRW) in Geneva, referring to Trump’s foreign policy doctrine. HRW also reacted to media reports that the US was considering quitting the council — before its term expires in 2019 — over the body’s treatment of Israel.

“A decision by the United States to withdraw from the UN Human Rights Council over its criticism of Israeli policy and its overall effectiveness would be a misguided and shortsighted step,” the group’s UN director Louis Charbonneau said in a statement. Pro-Israel groups have repeatedly noted that the Jewish state has been targeted by more rights council resolutions than any other nation. Palestinian president Mahmud Abbas, who addressed the opening session, said his people’s issue would be a “litmus test” for the council’s effectiveness. Assuming the US keeps its seat, there is “significant concern” about Washington’s capacity to take a leadership role based on Trump’s early moves, according to Fisher.