Trump vs Harris: Competing visions for a warming world

Author: AFP

“Drill, baby, drill” versus championing green energy: Donald Trump and Kamala Harris offer starkly opposing visions on climate, with the outcome of the US presidential race poised to shape the planet’s warming trajectory.

Neither candidate has outlined a comprehensive platform on climate, an issue that remains far from the center of the US campaign, despite the country being the world’s second-largest emitter of greenhouse gases, after China.

But their positions are no mystery. Former president Trump has long denounced climate change as a “hoax” and pledged to reverse the climate-friendly policies of the Biden-Harris administration if elected.

A Trump victory could significantly slow the pace of the green transition, dashing hopes of meeting critical long-term warming targets. A US retreat from climate diplomacy would undermine global efforts to reduce reliance on fossil fuels.

Even before the January inauguration, his election would immediately weaken the influence of US negotiators at the COP29 UN climate summit, set to begin just six days after the vote.

Greater commitments from wealthy nations like the United States are seen as essential to boosting financial support for vulnerable developing countries, a key focus of this year’s talks.

During his presidency, Republican Trump withdrew from the landmark Paris Agreement and has vowed to do so again if reelected, after President Joe Biden restored US participation.

To meet its Paris obligations, the United States committed to the ambitious goal of cutting its greenhouse gas emissions in half by 2030, compared to 2005 levels. By 2023, it had achieved an 18 percent reduction, according to the Rhodium Group.

“We have to really stay the course, and that would be a complete reversal under Trump,” according to Leah Stokes, a political scientist at UC Santa Barbara, who specializes in climate.

“The outcome of the American election will have ramifications for the whole planet,” she told AFP.

Harris, who attended COP28 where the United States played a key role in striking a deal to phase out fossil fuels, “is committed to continuing and building upon the United States’ international climate leadership,” according to her campaign website. As a senator, she co-sponsored a “Green New Deal” resolution calling for a drastic reduction in greenhouse gas emissions — dubbed the “Green New Scam” by Trump.

In 2019, as a Democratic primary candidate, she called for a ban on fracking — a controversial and highly polluting process that has made the US a top producer of natural gas and crude oil but comes with steep costs to the climate as well as local water and air quality. She has since changed her tune due to the political realities in Pennsylvania, a key swing state where the fracking industry plays an important economic role.

As she campaigns across the country, she has made little mention of climate change.

In her only televised debate with Trump, she defended the need for “diverse sources of energy,” even boasting that under the Biden-Harris administration, “we have had the largest increase in domestic oil production in history.”

This position has drawn quiet criticism from some supporters.

Still, she continues to enjoy broad backing from environmental groups, who are encouraged by her overall track record — from taking on oil companies as California’s attorney general to casting the tie-breaking vote on the “Inflation Reduction Act,” which has driven unprecedented investment in green energy.

Share
Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

  • Pakistan

PTI’s central political committees raise questions about Bushra Bibi’s involvement

On Wednesday, the core and political committees of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) deliberated on Bushra Bibi's…

19 hours ago
  • Pakistan

‘Final call turns out to be missed call’

In a scathing criticism, Information Minister Attaullah Tarar slammed Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) after the party…

21 hours ago
  • Pakistan

SC rejects suo motu notice plea on fatalities during PTI protest

The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court has rejected the PTI plea seeking to take…

21 hours ago
  • Pakistan

Finance ministry sees Nov inflation dropping to 5.8-6.8%

The first four months of the current fiscal year showed better than expected improvement marked…

21 hours ago
  • Pakistan

Govt says Afghans can’t live in Islamabad without NOC after Dec 31

Federal Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has announced that from December 31, no Afghan nationals will…

21 hours ago
  • Editorial

Ceasefire & Crossfire

The ceasefire between Hezbollah and Israel, two longstanding rivals, was welcomed by the people of…

21 hours ago