Supreme Court conviction of PM

Author: Malik Muhammad Ashraf

We are back to the crass politics of the 1990s, marked by intense polarisation and political vendetta. This brand of politics not only culminated in the derailment of democracy in the country but also left deep scars on the political landscape, which continue to haunt the Pakistani nation. The Sharif brothers enjoy the dubious distinction of starting that despicable drama in collaboration with the establishment then and now again share the blame of putting the clock back in connivance with other reactionary forces. They do not seem to have learnt from their past mistakes. They are crying hoarse from every convenient rooftop to urge the prime minister (PM) to abdicate power on moral grounds after the Supreme Court (SC) verdict but do not realise that it is also their moral obligation not to mislead the people on crucial national issues. Their actions are also tantamount to politicising the judiciary.

True, the SC has convicted the PM of contempt of court, but that is not the end of the road. The PM has the right of appeal and until such time that appeal is heard and a final verdict given, he remains the chief executive legally as well as constitutionally. The Pakistan Bar Council has also admitted this fact and thrown its weight behind the PM. The Islamabad High Court in a petition seeking disqualification of the PM has also observed that the SC in its verdict has not disqualified the PM from holding the office of the chief executive. In the backdrop of this irrefutable evidence as regards the constitutional position of the PM, the insistence by the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) that Syed Yousaf Raza Gilani has ceased to be the legal PM is absolutely untenable and extremely misleading.

The opposition, particularly the PML-N, is so blinded by its lust for power and animosity towards the PPP-led coalition government that it did not even hesitate to ask the British prime minister not to play host to Syed Yousaf Raza Gilani as Prime Minister of Pakistan. They were not alone in this sabre rattling; a section of the media sympathetic to their cause and essentially hostile to the present government also joined this shameful exercise. Nobody would grudge the legitimate right of the opposition to grill the government on issues of national importance but it is certainly not desirable to pull the rug from under the feet of the chief executive embarking on a foreign visit.

To an anodyne observer, the visit coming in the backdrop of a row between Pakistan and the US regarding resumption of NATO supplies and the continuing deadlock was of immense significance as the UK is the closest and major ally of the US in the war on terror and is in a position to help resolve the stalemate amicably. The issue did come up for discussion between the two leaders and it provided an excellent opportunity for Pakistan to clarify its position on the subject and the stakes that it has in re-engaging with the US and NATO in a manner that meets Pakistan’s concerns and is also mutually beneficial. The developments on this issue after the visit do suggest that there is a significant movement towards resolving the conundrum. Pakistan has been invited to the Chicago Conference without any preconditions. The matter has been deliberated upon at a high level meeting and also in the DCC. The Foreign Minister, Hina Rabbani Khar has also indicated the possibility of reopening the NATO supply routes, indicating that the ice has finally started melting and sentimentalism is giving way to prudence.

Contrary to the expectations of the PML-N and its cohorts, the British government extended a befitting protocol and welcome to Prime Minister Syed Yousaf Raza Gilani and paid glowing tribute to him in the following words. “Prime Minister Gilani was working to make democracy strong in Pakistan.” These words coming from the leader of the mother of all democracies are indeed very reassuring and an acknowledgement of the courage and sagacity of the PPP leadership in ensuring continuation of the democratic process in the face of unremitting hostility by its opponents, conspiracies of the elements inimical to democratic norms, and some controversial decisions by the more than independent judiciary.

On the bilateral plank also, the visit has been successful. The two sides agreed to enhance their bilateral trade from the current level of Pounds 1.4 billion to 2.5 billion by 2015 in pursuance of the UK-Pakistan Enhanced Strategic Dialogue launched in 2011. The British leader acknowledged the sacrifices made by Pakistan in furthering the objectives of the war on terror and expressed the resolve to help Pakistan in meeting its security challenges and curbing militancy, terrorism and religious extremism, which pose an existentialist threat to Pakistan.

The affirmation and endorsement by the UK of the contribution made by Pakistan to the war on terror is very encouraging as it would strengthen its position in regards to any future dialogue with the US and NATO. The UK has also played a pivotal role in ensuring duty-free access of Pakistani products to the EU market, which represents an exponential boost to Pakistan’s foreign trade. The visit therefore was timely and productive. Such summit level interactions are never meaningless as they invariably help to create better understanding and enhancing bilateral cooperation between the countries involved, besides affording an opportunity for exchange of views on matters of global importance. They also help in resolving issues that cannot be tackled through normal diplomatic channels. The criticism hurled at the prime minister by the opposition for undertaking this visit smacks of their traditional cynicism rather than an objective appraisal of the obtaining circumstances and the benefits that will accrue to Pakistan.

The writer is a retired diplomat, a freelance columnist and a member of the visiting faculty of Riphah Institute of Media Sciences, Riphah International University, Islamabad. He can be reached at ashpak10@gmail.com

Share
Leave a Comment

Recent Posts

  • Cartoons

TODAY’S CARTOON

18 hours ago
  • Editorial

Lahore Smog

Perhaps, we should have waited a while before heralding the successes of the Punjab government's…

18 hours ago
  • Editorial

Opening Doors

The recent visit of Belarusian President Aleksandr Lukashenko to Pakistan, accompanied by a high-level delegation,…

18 hours ago
  • Op-Ed

The Unmaking of Pakistan – II

The misplaced priority for a strong Centre has always put the federal structure of the…

18 hours ago
  • Op-Ed

Living the Age of Technopolitics

As per Edward Said's Orientalism, the Imperialist nations took technical superiority as a matter of…

18 hours ago
  • Op-Ed

Climate Change and Smog Issues

Pakistan faces major challenges from climate change and air pollution, especially smog, which significantly affects…

18 hours ago