Augusto Pinochet used military force to overthrow a popularly elected president and rule Chile with an iron grip that saw thousands of his subjects tortured and killed. Yet, 50 years after Pinochet’s power grab, and despite his brutal legacy, the general continues to inspire admiration rather than condemnation among many in a country that remains deeply suspicious of the political left.
Pinochet “is the only dictator in Western contemporary history who, 50 years after a coup d’etat, is viewed favorably by more than a third of the population,” sociologist Marta Lagos of polling company Cerc-Mori told AFP. A survey conducted by Cerc-Mori in May found that 36 percent of people believe the general “liberated Chile from Marxism,” the highest figure measured in 28 years of polling — a tie with 2000.
With his dark glasses and military uniform, Pinochet was emblematic of the US-backed dictatorships that held sway over much of Latin America during the Cold War. He seized power in a bloody CIA-backed coup in 1973 that saw the world’s first elected Marxist leader, Salvador Allende, commit suicide in the presidential palace as troops closed in. Pinochet presided until 1990 over a period of economic prosperity, but also great cruelty. More than 3,200 people were killed or “disappeared” — abducted and presumed killed — by his security forces, and about 38,000 were tortured. After stepping down as president, Pinochet continued serving as head of the military for many years, and as a senator until 2002 — ensuring he was never brought to justice despite numerous court cases pending against him.
He died of a heart attack on December 10, 2006 aged 91, without ever stepping foot in a court. More than 50,000 people turned out to mourn him. In 2021, the general’s name was again on many people’s lips as the country prepared for a presidential election pitting leftist Gabriel Boric against far-right Pinochet-apologist Jose Antonio Kast. Kast vowed to address voters’ fears about the economy and crime and painted Boric as a communist in a country where many equate the left with the economic failure of Venezuela — many of whose nationals migrated to Chile to escape their homeland. Boric won, sweeping to power on a wave of public support for his ideas of turning the South American nation into a greener, more egalitarian welfare state. According to UN figures, the top one percent of the population of Chile holds a quarter of its wealth. This is largely ascribed to the Pinochet-era constitution supporting a neo-liberal economic model blamed for deep-rooted inequality.
Long silence — Yet, Boric’s alliance with Chile’s Communist Party made many uneasy among those who remembered the hardships suffered under Allende — in part due to a US economic blockade — followed by relative prosperity under Pinochet. Boric has faced many headwinds since taking power.
The young president’s first attempt at replacing the Pinochet-era constitution was rejected by voters after months of drafting, and in May, Kast’s far-right Republican Party got the most seats in elections for a new body that will write another.
Legislating has been difficult in a congress where right-wing parties hold half the seats, but no single political grouping has an absolute majority. Analysts say Pinochet’s staying power is the result of decades of brushing over his legacy, even under leftist governments, in an attempt to avoid deepening social division. It was not until 2000 that allegations of abduction, rape, murder, and torture began to be thoroughly and systematically investigated.